Estimating the radius of the Moon - The medieval way

TL;DR I myself learnt the method from this page here.

Having estimated the radius of Earth, the next step, celestially speaking, would be to estimate the radius of the Moon, our satellite and closest neighbor. And before we proceed any further, let me just point out the fact that the distances or sizes in astronomy are measured in angles and not in meters. From Earth, it looks to us as though the astronomical objects are moving on a celestial sphere and therefore, their motion can be quantified in terms of angular motion and sizes in angles. How to measure these angles you say? Well using a telescope of course! A telescope can be calibrated such that one can move it along or perpendicular to the horizon with milli-degree accuracy, helping us therefore to estimate the angular size of objects in the sky.

Now that we've cleared that, let's look at quantities in the Earth-Moon-Sun system that can actually be measured. We already know the radius of Earth. We can estimate the angular diameter of the Moon, and therefore of the Sun, using telescopes. It is measured to be 31 arcminutes or approximately half a degree. Why is the angular size of the Moon equal to the angular size of the Sun you ask? Hint : Eclipses!

Coming to point, using the small angle approximation, we can say that the ratio of angular size of the Moon and the angular size of the Earth's shadow at a distance equal to the distance between the Earth and the Moon is equal to the ratio of the actual diameter of the moon to the actual diameter of the Earth's shadow at that distance!


source



source

The next step towards measuring the radius of the Moon is to look for an equality among the angles mentioned above. We can clearly see that the angles A, B and C add up to 180 and so do the angles C, D and E. We can therefore say that the sum of angles A and B are equal to the sum of angles C and D. In the small angle approximation, we can roughly say that the angles D and E are equal to the ratio of the radius of Earth to the distance between the Earth and the Moon and the distance between the Earth and the Sun respectively. Angles A and B on the other hand are equal to the ratio of the radius of the Sun and half the diameter of the Earth's shadow to the distance between the Earth and the Sun and the Earth and the Moon respectively. After making use of the equality that the angular size of the Sun is equal to the angular size of the moon i.e the ratio of the radius of the Sun to the distance between the Earth and the Sun is equal to the ratio of the radius of the Moon to the distance between Earth and the Moon, we can finally get an equation for the radius of the Moon in terms of the radius of the Earth and the ratio of the angular size of the Earth's shadow to the angular size of the moon; all of which are measured! You can follow the math here and see that the radius of the Earth is 3.7 times the radius of the Moon.

And to put a cherry on top of everything, now that we know the radius of the Moon and it's angular size, we can measure the distance to the Moon! Voila, now we know the radius of the Earth, the radius of the Moon and the distance between the Earth and the Moon!

You can also refer to this page, which gives a halfhearted explanation as to how to measure the same.

Popular posts from this blog

Farewell to Enthought

I started my professional career at Enthought , at the Pune office in India, on Feb 29, 2016. Over the course of eight long years, I spent time at the Austin office in the US, the Cambridge office in the UK, and I worked remotely from India. I was let go on March 27, 2024 . I had an unbelievably great time. I had three amazing mentors - Pankaj Pandey, Senganal Thirunavukkarasu, and Mark Dickinson. Pankaj mentored me in my first year at Enthought. I started paying attention to the craft of software after working with him. Senganal started mentoring me in my second year at Enthought, and continues to mentor me, even after the both of us have moved on from Enthought. He instilled professionalism in me, ensuring that the code I wrote produced precise scientific results, and that I tackled the known unknown aspects of a project first, to ensure timely communication about project progress. I was eager to manage people at the time and Senganal made me realize that I didn't want to manage ...
Read more

Arxiv author affiliations using Python

So, I wanted to get author affiliation information from papers on arXiv. arXiv provides with an API to bulk query their database and get information. Following that, I look for the attribute 'arxiv:affiliation' in the html data. Here's the code - import urllib from BeautifulSoup import BeautifulStoneSoup   url = 'http://export.arxiv.org/api/query?search_query=all:astro&start=0&max_results=1000'   data = urllib.urlopen(url).read() soup = BeautifulStoneSoup(data) #print(soup.prettify()) #list = soup.findAll('arxiv:affiliation') #for i in range(len(list)): #        print list[i].contents   test = [tag.string for tag in soup.findAll('arxiv:aiffiliation')] Now, the problem I'm having is that I'm getting affiliation of all authors which I want to split into sets of affiliations of authors of a paper, which I'm stuck on at the moment. Once I get that part, I can move on to the next part of this pet project, displaying these...
Read more

Elementary (particle physics), my dear Watson

Ground Control to Major Tom:  Shruti Patel checking in. Since my dear friend and fellow-physicist Rahul Poruri is homeward bound, and shall remain there for a week, I'm stepping in to continue his tradition of daily posts to Astronut . Even as I write, I'm not quite sure what this post is going to be about, so please forgive me for occasional rants and digressions.  By the way Rahul, I totally resent you for the name of this blog- I'm never going to start my own blog because there's no way I'll come up with a name as cool as Astronut! For now, I shall try and be happy with being a guest writer! Before I begin, a little bit on who I am and what I do; so that you can trust that my general views on science- particle physics in particular- are not entirely baseless. I graduated with a masters in Physics from IIT Madras in July this year, and I'm currently working towards (an eventual) PhD with the Theory Group at the Deutsches Electronen-Synchrotron (DESY)...
Read more